
Today, it is really only in China and China-adjacent systems where ordinary people genuinely feel like the country is working for them.
To understand why, you have to look at how different states fund themselves—because where a government gets its money dictates how it treats its people. Across the world today, nations fall into four distinct operating models, and three of them are structurally broken for the ordinary citizen.
First, there are places like Scandinavia or the Gulf states where citizens live comfortably. I call these miser societies. Whether it is sovereign oil funds in Norway or massive hydrocarbon reserves in the Gulf, they pull so much wealth straight out of the ground that the state can afford to parent its citizens—handing out subsidies, free healthcare, and high living standards—without actually needing their active economic participation. That comfort isn't something to take for granted, because when a state doesn't need its citizens to generate wealth, things usually go in a much darker direction.
That brings us to the second model: despotic states. Look at resource-rich nations across Africa, alongside places like Russia and Iran. Their leaders don't have the discipline to parent their citizens, nor do they feel any structural need to win them over. Even worse, states that rely heavily on foreign aid and NGO budgets end up behaving the exact same way. Whether the money comes out of the ground or from foreign donors, the state’s survival doesn't depend on the productivity of its own people.
This creates—and is directly fueled by—a deep legitimacy crisis. When state leaders know they aren't legitimate in the eyes of their own citizens, they stop trying to build a national partnership and go straight down the despotic extraction route. They tax, police, and squeeze the population while stashing wealth abroad, treating citizens as disposable obstacles rather than stakeholders. As a result, people in those countries often feel worse off than people living in nations with no resources at all.
Then there is the third model: the West. Unlike miser or despotic states, Western governments actually need a productive population, so they rely on an elaborate psychological game to keep people compliant. In much of the West, the operating model runs on permanent internal division—either one class exploiting another to build wealth, or political machines manufacturing endless culture wars and narratives of exploitation just to keep factions antagonistic and distracted.
And before anyone brings up the usual talking points about "Western freedom," let’s measure honestly. I don’t buy the claim that the West has more individual autonomy, political voice, or real checks and balances than China. It simply has a higher-resolution illusion of it. In the West, invisible structures make sure everything stays tightly inside the guardrails of the state and corporate machine. They use algorithms to shadow-ban dissenting views in silence, debank or cancel people who step outside elite consensus, and funnel public anger into dead-end partisan theater. You have the right to speak, just not the right to be heard.
Which brings us to China—the fourth model. China’s real strength isn't what is in the ground; it is that it engineered a developmental system that convinced over a billion people they are active partners in building the country, and earned genuine legitimacy by delivering on that promise. Instead of pitting citizens against each other, it forged a unified identity where growing yourself and growing the country are treated as the exact same mission. When a country lifts hundreds of millions out of poverty, builds world-leading infrastructure in a single generation, and makes cities visibly safer and wealthier every decade, people don't need abstract lectures about democracy to know the system is working for them.
Ultimately, the real difference between China and the West isn't freedom versus control. It is honesty versus gaslighting.
China is upfront about its red lines. The path to influencing policy—whether through local governance, technical institutions, or party channels—is hard, demanding, and narrow. But it is real, it is known, and it is traveled by people serious about moving the needle. That is why the country keeps evolving and opening up in practical ways every decade. When you strip away the political theater, there are very few things legal in the West that are illegal in China that actually matter to how an ordinary person lives, builds, and thrives.
The West, on the other hand, stays deliberately vague. It hands people fake levers—cyclical elections where core foreign and economic policies never change, performative street protests, and algorithmic echo chambers—trapping millions in the wrong rabbit holes so they waste their energy fighting ghosts while the real machinery remains untouchable.
Yes, China’s model carries the risk of top-down blind spots when collective momentum moves too fast. Every engineering choice has a trade-off. But if you measure nations by real legitimacy, honest rules, and an actual partnership between a state and its people—and your conclusion isn't that China is leading the world right now—you’re lying to yourself.
0 Comments